A former stepparent with minimal parenting time does not owe a duty of child support, per the Colorado Court of Appeals.
Back in 2019, the court of appeals issued a ground-breaking decision, A.C.H., which held that a psychological parent who sought court-ordered parenting time also had a duty to pay child support. See our blog post on a psychological parent’s duty to pay support for a discussion of the A.C.H. decision.
The A.C.H. court pointed out that it was not trying to create a new class of child support obligor, but instead its ruling was limited to psychological parents who had (1) established themselves as parents, rather than just guardians, and (2) sought court-ordered parenting time against the biological parent. Relevant to the new appellate decision is the fact that the psychological parent in A.C.H. ended up with a two-state parenting plan and 107 overnights.
The issue in Manly, an unpublished decision, was whether a child support obligation can be imposed upon a psychological parent who “does not have any decision-making and enjoys only limited and infrequent parenting time with the child.” ¶ 1.
Trial Court Ordered Parenting Time & Child Support
During the parties’ marriage, the parties had three children together. But at issue in the appeal was the mother’s youngest child, born during the marriage, but to a different father, so the husband was only the child’s stepfather, not a biological parent.
Stepfather Awarded Some Parenting Time
The husband/stepparent petitioned for dissolution, seeking an allocation of parental responsibilities over all four children, including his stepchild. The trial court named him primary residential parent over the parties’ three joint children, and awarded him parenting time with the stepchild of one weekend per month and certain holidays/breaks. The court did not give the husband joint decision-making, but did require the mother and the child’s biological father to confer with him on major decisions.
Stepparent Ordered to Pay Child Support
The trial court characterized its parenting time award to the stepparent as “a fair amount of rights”, so applying the A.C.H. decision, ordered him to pay child support for his stepchild, and to pay one-half of his medical and agreed-upon extracurricular activity expenses.
The mother appealed the award of parenting time to the stepfather, and the stepfather appealed the child support order. The court of appeals affirmed the parenting time order, finding that the trial court properly applied the legal standard, but reversed the order for the stepparent to pay child support.
Court of Appeals – Minimal Parenting Time Not Justify Stepparent Child Support Obligation
At trial, the husband testified that he was “prepared and willing” to be financially responsible for his stepchild, but the court of appeals did not interpret that as an open offer to pay support no matter what. Instead, going into the final orders hearing, the stepparent had only every other weekend, and was trying to increase that, so his statements re: support were conditional upon his assuming a greater parental role. In the end, the trial court reduced his time from alternating weekends to one weekend per month.
Not all court-ordered parenting time for a psychological parent will result in support – the parental responsibilities ordered must be “significant enough… to give rise to a child support obligation.” Manly, ¶ 31.
The Court of Appeals contrasted the differences between the limited parenting time awarded to the stepparent in this case to A.C.H., which concerned “a psychological parent who fights for and obtains all of the same responsibilities of a legal parent.” A.C.H., ¶ 33:
- In A.C.H., the child’s biological parent had been absent since birth, and the psychological parent had, since birth, been the only father figure the child had known, with the mother’s “encouragement and blessing” for ten years (four years during their relationship, and six years after the parties broke up).
- The psychological parent in A.C.H. was awarded 107 overnights. While the Manly decision does not spell out how many overnights the stepparent received, one weekend per month would come to 24 per year, plus some holidays, so likely under 40 nights.
- The psychological parent in A.C.H. had joint decision-making, unlike the stepparent in Manly.
- The stepparent’s time in Manly coincided with the time the child spent with his half-siblings who lived with the stepparent and who were bonded with one another.
Contrasting the A.C.H. and Manly decisions, the takeaway appears to be that there is no bright-line rule on when a psychological parent owes a duty of support. Merely seeking court-ordered parenting time is not sufficient to trigger the obligation, nor is parenting time which the Manly court characterized as:
- “limited and infrequent parenting time”, or
- “fair amount of rights”
Instead, the threshold for a child support obligation is:
- “significant enough parental responsibilities.” Manly.
- “all of the same responsibilities of a legal parent.” A.C.H.
Infrequent weekends alone will not suffice, at least not without a combination of more time than that, and perhaps even a requirement of joint decision-making before a support obligation can be ordered.
More Information on Stepparent Child Support Obligation
Colorado has a history of requiring non-parents to pay support under limited circumstances. For a comprehensive discussion, see the Child Support and Third Party Non-Parents article in the Colorado Family Law Guide.
FAQ – Stepparent Child Support & Parenting
Is it step-parent or stepparent?
In the U.S., the word stepparent is generally spelled without a hyphen – see, e.g., the Merriam-Webster Dictionary. In Great Britain, the word step-parent is generally hyphenated, see, e.g., the Oxford English Dictionary.
Do you have to be married to be a stepparent?
Legally, a stepparent means the spouse of a child’s parent, so yes, marriage is required. However, upon divorce, a former stepparent who has become a psychological parent may be able to seek stepparent visitation.
Does stepparent income affect child support?
In Colorado, a stepparent’s income does not affect the child support obligation of either parent. However, a stepparent with “significant” court-ordered parenting may be ordered to pay child support, in which case his income would count.
Do stepparents have rights?
Without a court order, a stepparent does not have any parental rights. A stepparent who has become the psychological parent to a child can seek parenting time upon divorce from the child’s parent.
Can a stepparent get custody?
A stepparent who has become a psychological parent can get court-ordered parenting time, but it would be rare to receive full custody over the objection of a fit biological parent.
Award-Winning Colorado Allocation of Parental Responsibilities Lawyers
U.S. News & World Report calls Graham.Law one of the Best Law Firms in America, and our managing partner is a Colorado Super Lawyer. Our family law attorneys have years of experience helping clients navigate the Colorado legal system. We know Colorado divorce & family law inside and out, from complex multi-million dollar property or child custody cases to basic child support modifications.
For more information about our top-rated El Paso County family law firm, contact us by filling out our contact form, calling us at (719) 630-1123 to set up a free consult, or click on:
- Why Graham.Law for your Colorado Family Law Case. Learn about the benefits of hiring divorce specialists to help you.
- Our Colorado Springs Family Law Team. The great attorneys & paralegals at Graham.Law.
- Colorado Family Law Guide. The internet’s most comprehensive resource for attorneys and clients alike.
- Military Divorce Guide. Addresses specialized family law issues that arise when one spouse is in the military.
Colorado Family Law. Period.