Marital Property Includes Separate Property Increase in Value
In a Colorado dissolution of marriage, an asset owned by a spouse prior to marriage remains the property of that spouse (per C.R.S. 14-10-113(2)). But that does not increase a separate property increase in value. Only the principal amount brought into the marriage remains the spouse’s separate property.
If a separate property asset has increased in value during the marriage, that increase is marital property subject to division: “an asset of a spouse acquired prior to the marriage… shall be considered as marital property, for the purposes of this article only, to the extent that its present value exceeds the value at the time of the marriage…” C.R.S. 14-10-113(4). See also Balonson.1In re: Marriage of Balonson, 25 P.3d 28, 42 (Colo. 2001).
Error for Trial Court to Allocate Property Based Upon Market Forces
In view of this clear rule that a separate property increase is marital, it’s surprising when spouses try to argue to the contrary, and even more surprising when a judge divides the marital asset without treating the increases in separate property as divisible marital property.
A recent decision from the Colorado Court of Appeals held that it was reversible error for the trial court to set aside to a spouse most of the increase in the value of his premarital property without making specific findings as to how that would be equitable. Winick.2In re: Marriage of Winick (Colo.App. 2019) (Unpublished decision).
The husband had significant premarital property, and his separate property increase in value during the marriage was $474,000, while the wife’s premarital property had increased by just $63,000 during marriage. From that combined total appreciation of $537,000, the family law judge awarded the wife just 20% of the combined increase. The wife appealed, and the Court of Appeals reversed.
Citing Balanson, the court first noted that the increases in value of separate property are marital. And when dividing marital property between the spouses, C.R.S. 14-10-113(1) sets forth specific factors the court is required to consider in determining an equitable division.
The problem was not that the trial court divided the property unequally – while rare, that does happen once in a while because in a Colorado divorce the marital property must be divided equitably, not necessarily equally. The issue was that the trial court did so for an impermissible reason – because the separate property increase was only due to “market forces”, and not some efforts of the husband during the marriage.
Because an increase due to market forces was not a permissible reason to set aside marital property to a spouse, and the trial court did not make specific findings addressing the statutory factors to justify an unequal division, the Court of Appeals reversed.
While one of the factors the trial court could consider is contributions of separate property, the Court of Appeals made clear that this contribution does not include an increase due to market forces: “For assistance on remand, we note that marital appreciation as a result of market forces is not immune from equitable distribution.” Winick.3In re: Marriage of Winick (Colo.App. 2019), ¶ 19 (Unpublished decision).
The takeaway? In a Colorado divorce, the only way to protect a separate property increase in value from being equitably divided as part of the marital estate is to have a marital agreement (a prenup or a postnup) – indeed, clauses stating that increases in the value of a spouse’s premarital assets remain the separate property of that spouse are among the most common of clauses in marital agreements.
But don’t count on prevailing just because your attorney creatively argues that the other spouse did not contribute towards the asset will not work under this holding.
Award-Winning Colorado Springs Divorce Attorneys
U.S. News & World Report calls Graham.Law one of the Best Law Firms in America, and our managing partner is a Colorado Super Lawyer. Our family law attorneys have years of experience helping clients navigate the Colorado legal system. We know Colorado divorce & family law inside and out, from complex multi-million dollar property or child custody cases to basic child support modifications.
For more information about our top-rated El Paso County family law firm, contact us by filling out our contact form, calling us at (719) 630-1123 to set up a free consult, or click on:
- Why Graham.Law for your Colorado Family Law Case. Learn about the benefits of hiring divorce specialists to help you.
- Our Colorado Springs Family Law Team. The great attorneys & paralegals at Graham.Law.
- Colorado Family Law Guide. The internet’s most comprehensive resource for attorneys and clients alike.
- Military Divorce Guide. Addresses specialized family law issues that arise when one spouse is in the military.
Colorado Family Law. Period.